Hollywood Life reports:
"The cocktail was still in its glass and although Lindsay was aiming for photographer Jasper Rischen, it hit a cocktail waitress instead. But that’s just the beginning.
The cocktail waitress was fine with the exception of being soaked in alcohol. New York Magazine’s The Cut reports that suddenly the music went off and the lights came on with someone screaming: 'She’s bleeding!'
Two eyewitnesses tell HollywoodLife.com that an unidentified brunette woman, who was sitting near Lindsay on a white leather couch, 'cut her arm open' and was bleeding 'profusely.'"
Meanwhile, celeb gossip mega-site JustJared is trying to set the "facts" straight:
"RUMOR: She threw a champagne glass at a cocktail waitress.
JJ FACT: Lindsay was sitting on a white leather couch with friends and family when a photographer leaned over a wall behind her booth, tried to take a picture, and accidentally knocked over a glass. 'Lindsay and her friends were soaked in champagne,' a partygoer tells JustJared.com. 'But they grabbed a pile of napkins and cleaned it up quickly.'
RUMOR: She threw a drinking glass at a bleeding woman.
JJ FACT: A woman tripped while walking down a staircase adjacent to Lindsay’s booth. The glass she was holding shattered and sliced her arm open. Medics were called and the woman was taken to the hospital. 'Lindsay didn’t even see the girl trip,' a partygoer tells JustJared.com. 'She saw the bloody mess after the fact and then went over to the hotel’s owner [Andre Balazs] and chatted with him for awhile.'”
So, there you have it. Which side of the story will you believe? In all fairness, Lindsay doesn't have the most impressive track record. But shedding blood in the penthouse of a high-profile hotel? In public? That might be too trashy for even LiLo standards. She's got a reputation to uphold, after all!