/ / / /

The 12 Best Hotels in NYC: Fall 2010

November 3, 2010 at 10:57 AM | by | Comments (16)

For over six years now, we've been chronicling, photographing and filming the best and the worst in hotels around the world. And now it is time to impart our PH.D-like hotel wisdom on you in rankings form. You wanted the best and you got the best, the hottest hotels in New York City...LIST.

Our one criteria? All hotels on these lists must be HotelChatter tested and approved and in no way have these rankings been bought or influenced by eager hoteliers and/or pr reps.

Now, the rankings can and will change which is why our aim is to let you know who is moving up and down the charts on a seasonal basis.

In this inaugural Fall 2010 Best Hotels in New York City edition, we looked for hotels worthy of a holiday getaway. Yet while the holidays in NYC can be magical, the damage a New York City hotel stay does to your budget this time of year is not fun. We found sample price quotes using the HotelChatter booking engine and searching for rates between Nov. 29-Dec. 3. Of course, rates are not guaranteed and are subject to change.

  • 1

    The Surrey

    Elegant room decor, Daniel Boulud room service, a mini-bar that Don Draper would approve of and it's just steps away from Central Park.

    Room Rates: $400 a night
  • 2

    The Crosby Street Hotel

    Lovely from head to toe, a civilized respite in Soho and with a screening room on-site too. Now if only you could get a room.

    Room Rates: $500 a night
  • 3

    The Trump SoHo

    Undeniably Trump but the spacious rooms, Fendi furniture, Hudson River views and giant soaking tubs have won us over.

    Room Rates: $499 a night
  • 4

    The James New York

    Carefully considered design, amenities and art have delighted recent guests, despite not being totally finished (the restaurant is still to come.)

    Room Rates: $480 a night
  • 5

    Andaz Fifth Avenue

    Do it for free perks like WiFi, minibar snacks and even departure amenities. The generous rooms and the Fifth Ave location don't hurt either.

    Room Rates: $500 a night
  • 6

    Gansevoort Park

    A tri-level playground on the roof that includes pools and bars. Need we say more?

    Room Rates: $430 a night
  • 7

    The Chatwal

    Brings Art Deco glamour and seduction back to Midtown...at Uptown prices.

    Room Rates: $600 a night
  • 8

    Ace Hotel

    With a Michelin-starred restaurant, a coffee shop, sub shop, retail store and hot lobby scene, it's "ace" for deep-pocketed hipsters with ADD.

    Room Rates: $500 a night
  • 9

    W Downtown

    Futuristic design and innovative lighting schemes make it very un-W but Bliss toiletries and Whatever/Whenever service remains.

    Room Rates: $480 a night
  • 10

    The Cassa Hotel

    Simple rooms in midtown with luxurious touches like Frette linens, Dean & DeLuca amenities and 42-inch flatscreen TVs at a reasonable rate.

    Room Rates: $299 a night
  • 11

    The Standard Hotel

    Yes, it's overpriced dorm room chic but the scene has proved irresistible to the fashion crowds and celebrities.

    Room Rates: $500 a night
  • 12

    Smyth Tribeca

    A new bar, a "Top Chef" in the restaurant and the Kardashians have finally made this Thompson Hotel hot since opening nearly two years ago.

    Room Rates: $485 a night

Over the next few months we will roll out HotelChatter's Hotel Rankings for several other major cities so stay tuned. And if you have hotels you want us to check out, or questions on the list, you know where to leave comments.

HotelChatter editors, contributors, and tipsters all contributed to this report.

Comments (16)

Post a Comment

Really?

A few deserve to be there, but not in the spots you put them.  The fact that you don't have the Four Seasons or the Mandarin on there really make it hard to take the rest of the list seriously.  And Trump SoHo, Smyth, and Ganz Park really? Why?

These are the hotels...

that are hot right now. Being new was a big part of who made the list...

Four Seasons?

Um, the Four Seasons NYC is a run-of-the-mill Four Seasons for $1000 between Nov. 29-Dec. 3.  You go ahead and stay there, we are going to stay somewhere more alive, and better, for half the price...

um...really?

the cassa?!

How about the Gramercy Park Hotel?

This one should definitely be on the list -

http://www.onedayonehotel.com/?p=702


Luxury Hotels

Hey Really nice post for best hotels in NYC and also i will choose for best hotel in NYC thanks for posting. Leading Luxury Hotels

Trump Soho

The trump soho has such an amazing view of the city, i'd book it just for that!

I like your website

I really like your method of blogging. I bookmarked it to my bookmark web site listing and will probably be checking back soon. Pls check out my web site as effectively and let me know what you think. <a href="http://birthinjury-attorney.net">Birth Injury Attorney</a>

even more just WRONG

the ace is NOT the place! further proof of your uselessness to  Newhouse, trust me i  will comb this thing for mistakes and gaffes and out of itness  which isnt hard to find, good Lord you guys suck. www.curbedny.com any old day -  wrong wrong wrong a waste of Naste  cash.

CHEAP BEACH RESORTS

<a href="http://www.animeonlineworld.com/">ANIMEONLINE</a> | <a href="http://www.soccerworldgame.com/">SOCCER GAMES</a>

What about the Mercer

I am often booked to DJ at weddings and events in NYC.  I like the Mercer.  <a href="http://www.wedding-djs-london.co.uk">http://www.wedding-djs-london.co.uk</a>

Trump Was Great

I stayed at the Trump and it really did have a great view. The room was great too. I also stayed at the Trump in Las Vegas and it had a great view and I had a great time. The guy may have weird hair, but he does have great hotels! Alicia <a href="http://vapersgazette.com">Vaping</a>

The Trump SoHo

The Trump SoHo is amazing hotel. Great view :) regards, Pedrinho, <a href="http://www.howtolose-weight-info.com">Your Keyword</a>

http://www.gothamtransport.com"

 <a href="http://www.gothamtransport.com">Car shipping rates</a> at low prices!  Visit now to gothamtransport.com for free price quotes.

car shipping rates

<a href="http://www.gothamtransport.com">Car shipping rates</a> at low prices! Visit now to gothamtransport.com for free price quotes.

Why am I so tired?

Its the sign of great people,always help the seekers,as you have shared a great list of do follow blogs for seo experts.<a href="http://www.stressvitamin.net/">http://www.stressvitamin.net/</a>

Join the conversation!

Not a member? .