Close User Name Password
Hotel stories straight to your inbox:

Tags: / / / /

HotelChatter's Annual Hotel WiFi Report 2009

May 6, 2009 at 1:22 PM | by HotelChatter | 47 Comments

Using the complimentary Kimpton Hotel WiFi in the lobby and poolside at the Hotel Palomar Westwood

A HotelChatter Exclusive

When we did our first HotelChatter WiFi Report back in 2004, we focused on the few hotels and hotel chains that were offering free, reliable hotel wireless and those who weren't. Over the next couple of years, more and more hotels began addressing the issue of adding dependable wireless for their guests, both in-room and in-lobby. However, what we are seeing in 2009 is a trend towards the corrosion of the upkeep, reliability and "freeness" of hotel wireless services.

To our dismay, some hotels that boast free WiFi in their guestrooms offer the worst kind of WiFi you can get: the slow kind. Worse yet, just because you've forked over a daily fee for the internet service in your room, doesn't mean you're guaranteed a fail-safe, four-bar connection.

This year, we'll be looking at the hotels and chains that are putting a new spin on free and reliable service as well as those hotels that have fallen off the reliable WiFi wagon. We'll also touch on International hotel WiFi gems and rip-offs. Remember, just because your favorite brand gives it to you for free here at home doesn't mean you'll get it on your next trip abroad.

In short, our message to hoteliers in 2009 is this: don't make us rely on our iPhones, Blackberries, and 3G cards; we still rely on hotel WiFi. Offer us the dependable wireless connections we need for getting on our laptops, checking out online videos, stalking old friends on Facebook, tweeting, buying music and movies for the trip home (or even for the hotel room) — and maybe even getting some work done.

· Best Hotel WiFi 2009
· Worst Hotel WiFi 2009
· International WiFi Hotels 2009
· Connecting In-Room
· 2009 WiFi Chart

These reports were compiled by HotelChatter editors and information gathered came from in-person trips to these hotels and member and reader emails and comments between May 2008 and May 2009.

47 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. BS

    HotelChatter Member

    Awesome chart!

    I think free in the lobby should be mandatory!
    May 6, 2009 at 2:08 PM
  1. kjb

    HotelChatter Member

    Finally, WiFi Hotels You'd Want To Stay In

    Sorry to "dis" you Best Western, but Aloft and Hyatt Place are actually fun places to stay--WiFi is just icing on the tech-cake.

    Looking at the awesome wrap-up chart finally made me realize something: The worse the hotel brand the cheaper the WiFi. C'mon Ritz and JDub Marriott, not all of us can just expense it on the Platinum!

    May 6, 2009 at 2:22 PM
  1. markj

    HotelChatter

    W WiFi Wondering

    I still don't get the W hotel WiFi policies.  It is free in the lobby in SF, use to be free in Union Square in NYC, and was never free in Times Square.  Seems you never know what you are going to get with W.  

    However, aloft, hyatt place, marriott residence inn + courtyards -- all free and clear all the time.

    May 6, 2009 at 2:25 PM
  1. Jenna

    HotelChatter Member

    i think

    I think all the W's are free in all the lobbies, but like, I don't really want to be sitting amongst the zebra print pillows and the whole mess trying to get my work done. Especially in the event that there is "nnst nnst nnst" music playing. Although my pink macbook would look cute next to the pink martini i'd be drinking, I guess.
    I do remember them telling me at the W hoboken that they charge guests to use the biz center though, which is kind of weird.
    May 6, 2009 at 3:21 PM
  1. cmb

    HotelChatter Member

    Great Chart!

    What an awesome resource!

    I second kjb and was also surprised that the pricier the hotel, the less likely they are to offer free wifi. Mybe they figure if you can afford their rooms you can afford to cough up the extra for internet access.

    May 6, 2009 at 4:13 PM
  1. AndrewC

    HotelChatter Contributing Editor

    Embassay Suites - Free

    I was just at the Embassy Suites in Charleston SC a few weeks back and the WiFi in the rooms/lobby was free. The front desk said all Embassy Suites have free WiFi - but I cant verify that other than her comment and what this particular hotel had.
    May 6, 2009 at 4:44 PM
  1. globetrotting gourmet

    HotelChatter Member

    five star guide

    I just printed this guide out and threw it in my wallet. I'm sure it will come in handy with my frequent travels and avert the damned if I, damned if I don't, $20+ daily internet connection fees I find myself paying over and over again. Thank you.
    May 6, 2009 at 9:52 PM
  1. Omri

    HotelChatter Member

    Wireless router

    Does anyone carry around those little wireless routers that you just plug in? I've had some success with carrying around full-sized routers and using them to get wireless access. Just logging in through the router works - I've never had to spoof a MAC address or anything like that. I'm wondering if the less robust small ones work.
    May 7, 2009 at 3:22 AM
  1. Jenna

    HotelChatter Member

    Airport Express, etc

    Hmm. Some tech people also recommend the Airport Express to, like, get around paying-per-computer when you have to connect multiple computers in a single hotel room. Check out this story.
    May 7, 2009 at 8:50 AM
  1. Ferbdog

    HotelChatter Member

    Bellagio Vegas is Aweful!

    Tech support was useless. They had no idea how to work with a Mac. Will NEVER stay there again.
    May 7, 2009 at 9:19 AM
  1. HG2

    HotelChatter Member

    New York Helmsley

    Went first to a Kimpton in the city and, although they claim free, it was not. Next trip in stayed here and it was free in the room, lobby and restaurant.
    May 7, 2009 at 9:27 AM
  1. Jenna

    HotelChatter Member

    Another cool product for WiFi junkies

    Anyone else see this in the NYTimes this morning? This is kind of glorious: The MiFi; $40 a month, good WiFi ANYWHERE off Verizon's 3G network.
    http://www.nytimes.com/2009/05/07/technology/personaltech/07pogue.html?_r=2
    May 7, 2009 at 9:41 AM
  1. juliab

    HotelChatter Contributing Editor

    kimpton

    i didn't even notice i had to sign up to their programme, but that would explain why i got a nice little card through the letterbox after i stayed there. think US is better than europe for not charging generally - am sick and tired of english country houses whacking £10 on the bill every time i go..
    May 7, 2009 at 11:06 AM
  1. EricRosen

    HotelChatter Member

    so useful!

    This is one of the best guides ever! Nothing more disappointing than a bad connection on the road...now I can avoid it!
    May 7, 2009 at 3:11 PM
  1. inncritic

    HotelChatter Member

    Other WiFi Workrounds

    All of the major US Wireless companies have their own version of MiFi (Verizon)...T Mobile has one and Sprint and AT&T do as well.  They are little pocket devices that look just like thumb drives and plug into a USB port on your laptop.  They are in most major cities, every bit as good as the WiFi you get in most hotel properties, and Sprint just announced they are launching 4G around the country. You can use them while moving in taxis or while waiting in airports too. Just about everyone charges $30-$40/month.  And they are portable, so companies can sign up for them and lend them to employees so they can be shared among workers who are travelling when others are not.
    In Europe (where nothing is free, and WiFi is the Euro equivalent of $35+/day)you can buy them from most European carriers as well. (BT Cell and Orange in the UK; Orange & SFR in France).  If you commit to 12 months of service, you can get unlimited portable service for €30/month, which is less than a hotel would charge for a day!  The catch:  most European service providers will only sign up residents of their countries, so you may need to enlist the aid of an overseas co-worker or friend who will sign up on their behalf. (Oh, and don't roam from country to country with them, because unlimited plans often don't cross national borders).   A little inconvenient, but it sure beats being gouged.
    May 7, 2009 at 5:38 PM
  1. bbphx

    HotelChatter Member

    Great report!

    Also interesting to report would be whether or not hotels throttle bandwidth.  Here at The Clarendon in Phoenix we don't, so our free wifi is usually getting speeds at around 4000-6000K on speedtest.net - always a great site to go to when you check into a hotel.  The interesting bit - we're seeing more and more people commenting on check-in that they have their own aircards, which is a welcome trend.  

    Perhaps one day in 5-10 years, you'll see:

    • more and more hotels without wi-fi (everyone will have their own 3g/4g/5g or wi-max cards),

    • no phones (everyone seems to have a mobile these days, and even though we offer free worldwide calls, people rarely pick up their phones in their rooms!  we're even getting more and more people calling from their mobile phones to the front desk because they're too lazy to get up and pick up one of the two cordless telephones in their rooms - seriously!),

    • no TVs (hey, I tell you what, so many people tell me now that they don't even turn on their TV when they stay in their room, and we have nice 42"-50" TVs - they're using hulu and websites to watch their shows - oh, and by the way, we don't have any pay per view, and no movie channels, and rarely even get a question from a guest if we have them).

    • no radios/alarm clocks/cd players/stereos.  People bring their laptops/phones along with their headphones/earbuds.  People are trained to waking up to their phone alarm... they can't even figure out most alarm clocks these days.

    • power strips at every bed and desk.... we already have them in almost every room, both at the bed and at the desk.  nobody should ever have to crawl around.

    As technology becomes more portable and "attached to the person" rather than "attached to the room", it's going to be interesting to see how this affects the bottom line... imagine hotels that don't have to install and maintain phone systems, wi-fi networks, tv's... that's a lot of saved wiring, and only helps hotels become more and more green.  Even light switches are becoming wireless so you don't have to run copper wire to and from every switch.

    When articles are written about the "future guest room" it always seems to be from the perspective of companies trying to sell products and use more resources.  I'd love someone to ask me as a independent hotel owner with a bit of geek in me what I think the future will hold.   I think it'll be about  comfort and appointments, not technology, because people will bring their own technology with them.

    Thanks/Ben
    Owner/GM
    The Clarendon Hotel
    Phoenix, AZ

    May 8, 2009 at 2:52 PM
  1. steve10

    HotelChatter Member

    no free wifi but free swimming...sure!

    I find it really funny when a hotel says they are charging for wifi because its a service not everyone uses (Thompson) and therefore they shouldn't build it into the rates to provide it "free" to all guests.  What about all those swimming pools that hardly anyone uses.  With this reasoning they should really start charging for the use of the pool since I know most guests never use the pool.  As a matter of fact I would bet that a lot more guests use the wifi than use the swimming pool.
    May 9, 2009 at 8:10 AM
  1. markj

    HotelChatter

    Caesar's WiFi Failure

    Yet another Las Vegas Hotel wifi fail:  Caesar's Augustus Tower.  Your internet will be tethered, though at least the ethernet works.
    May 11, 2009 at 10:54 AM
  1. JulieJewel

    HotelChatter Member

    Firmdale Hotels London

    still can't get over they charge close to 40 $ a night for wifi usage (per computer!!)
    May 11, 2009 at 7:17 PM
  1. guestnetworks

    HotelChatter Member

    You wouldn't believe some of the calls we get

    From many, many comments on-line, I know that we are one of the few companies that operate truly reliable Internet services for hotels - and I understand just how bad many of the contractors AND franchise operators are.

    Of course everyone reading this is reasonable and competent, but in general we get:

    • 50% of calls are for help turning built in wireless cards on, or just connecting to a network
    • 10% of callers simply need to reboot
    • 10% of calls are for non-PC devices, including iPhones, PSPs, PS3, Wii, XBox 360, and even TiVos
    • 5% of callers need to exit/restart Internet Explorer (or get a better browser)
    • 5% tried to start another application before their browser and didn't get the user agreement
    • 5% have background apps or spyware taking up 40 or more sessions, killing legitimate traffic (that's 90% of all complaints about network speed)
    • 3/4 of all Mac users can't look up their current IP (DHCP) address
    • 5% of calls are generated by problems with the ISP, which no one else can resolve or prevent (Qwest being the worst by far)
    • 1% are problems with the guest's PC that we cannot fix over the phone (like replacing a hard drive)
    • 1 guest in 20,000 will have a problem connecting that is not related to their PC and cannot be resolved remotely
    • Callers over 50 take twice as long on average, over 65 is 4x (I don't mention this flippantly, I'm coming up on 40 quickly)

    So what gives us hope? For every guest that refuses help (0.5%), we hear thanks and appreciation from 5 times that many.

    And even though the front desk staff at every hotel will say 'several' guests are having trouble when they mean one, and 'all' or 'every' guest when they mean two (I wish I was kidding!), we never hesitate to check all the connections.

    If I were only given the option of talking to in-house staff with limited training (and probably no admin access to the network) instead of a phone number, I would know not to return to that hotel.

    May 12, 2009 at 12:01 AM
  1. cheap hotel rates

    HotelChatter Member

    Tripadvisor Reviews about this ammenity

    You know what amazes me is I was reading some reviews particularly for the Sheraton on Cocoa Beach and I found that people though that hotel "sucked" because the Wifi was down for a day.  My biggest problem with this is you are on a beach, a beautiful beach, with fantastic tempratures and all you have to make you happy is WIFI?  Put the laptop down for a few hours and walk on the beach and listen to the ocean.  I can't believe how important this has become.  10 years ago you were lucky to get dialup in a hotel, and nobody used it!
    May 12, 2009 at 9:09 PM
  1. kitsura

    HotelChatter Member

    Free Wifi in Four Points by Sheraton

    I'm currently staying in a Four Points hotel and I don't see anything that has changed. They still charge for in-room wifi and internet access. But lobby and restaurant wifi access is free.
    May 13, 2009 at 12:35 AM
  1. MissBelle

    HotelChatter Member

    Is it WiFi or is it fake dial up ?

    I recently had the grave misfortune to stay at the Comfort Inn Central Park West in NY. It's a super location, but a dump of a hotel. They advertise free wifi.  IF, IF you can connect to it, the speeds are slower than dial up.  Hotel management is well aware of the long existing problem, but refuses to do anything to remedy it. Needless to say, I would never stay at this horrible hotel again.  Sure would be nice if hotels advertised their broadband speeds.  For those of us who work constantly on the web, it would be nice to know for biz travel.

    Shame on you Comfort Inn / Choice Hotels.

    May 17, 2009 at 1:21 PM
  1. juliana

    HotelChatter Editor

    Westin St. Francis Lobby FAIL

    Just tried to log onto Westin St. Francis lobby WiFi. it was so miserably slow--the landing page couldn't even load. i dont care if the beds are heavenly, the westin WiFi is crap.
    May 18, 2009 at 4:02 PM
  1. GarryWert

    HotelChatter Member

    Common thing

    Unfortunately, that's a common thing And there's no chance to solve the problem, as new people will always come to such hotels. I travel with my digital piano and have to send tracks to different places. It's very annoying when you cannot do what you paid for.
    June 7, 2009 at 9:38 AM
  1. hankjmatt

    HotelChatter Member

    I don't really want to be sitting

    I don't really want to be sitting amongst the zebra print pillows and the whole mess trying to get my work done. Especially in the event that there is "nnst nnst nnst" music playing. Although my pink macbook would look cute next to the pink martini i'd be drinking, I guess. I do remember club penguin telling me at the W hoboken that they charge guests to use the biz center though, which is kind of weird.
    June 17, 2009 at 2:12 AM
  1. markj

    HotelChatter

    London Free Hotel WiFi

    Found free, reliable, wifi @ Hotel Zetter, http://bit.ly/3Ml54 in London today.  Wahoo.
    June 19, 2009 at 10:52 AM
  1. juliana

    HotelChatter Editor

    Thompson hotels are struggling

    to provide good wireless service to its customers. Not only did they make it a pay-for service this year, they also made it a non-working connection. Grrr. I had problems the other week at Smyth Tribeca and JetSetCD had a network fail the other day at the Hollywood Roosevelt. Perhaps they should go back to offering it for free?
    June 19, 2009 at 6:15 PM
  1. ChicagoET

    HotelChatter Member

    All Philadelphia Marriotts - Awful WiFi and Wired

    So, I travel to Philadelphia each week and so far have stayed at the Courtyard, Residence Inn, and Executive Marriott (all within 2 blocks).  The Residence Inn offers free WiFi.  It has to be the slowest I've ever experienced.  The Courtyard and Executive Marriott have equally awful wired broadband at a whopping 90kbps... downloads drop after a few minutes.  It is absolutely awful.  I have called Network Helpdesk in all three hotels and none of them have been able to do anything but reset the slow connection to a new slow connection.
    June 22, 2009 at 1:30 PM
  1. Jasonhiex

    HotelChatter Member

    Wifi rip off

    It doesn't cost much to offer free wifi, and if you are on a business trip at the end of the day you are going to go for the hotel with the free wifi, not that one that makes you pat for the privilege!
    Jason hotels cheltenham
    June 24, 2009 at 4:56 AM
  1. Dale Thompson

    HotelChatter Member

    This is brilliant!

    Thanks so much.

    There's nothing worse than going somewhere on business and finding that the WiFi on offer is worse than dial-up. I'll definitely be making use of this resource in future. Thanks again. Dale Yacht Charter.

    June 30, 2009 at 9:52 AM
  1. comment

    HotelChatter Member

    I Love Wifi

    I really like a hotel provides Wifi Internet connection to use free of charge.
    July 9, 2009 at 3:41 AM
  1. thegooroo

    HotelChatter Member

    WiFi

    I agree with what the 5th commenter said (cmb). I've always found that the more expensive hotels do not offer free WiFi, but the cheaper ones do. The most reasonable explanation is that the expensive hotels know guests have more money, thus they are more likely to pay for WiFi.
    July 23, 2009 at 2:34 AM
  1. bretthexum

    HotelChatter Member

    great info

    I travel extensively and appreciate the report.  I'll post links on my Computer Help Forum and PC Tips and Tricks blog.

    I believe Hilton/HGI/Hampton has the best wireless from the properties I've visited.  

    August 14, 2009 at 10:10 PM
  1. Zauberer

    HotelChatter Member

    Free WiFi

    As a magician (Zauberer) I travel a lot and spend a lot of time in hotels. Of course I want to use the WiFi but most of the time the bandwidth is very poor. This usually results is me grabbing a book and reading some pages instead of complaining about the connection. Greets the Zauberkünstler
    August 15, 2009 at 6:32 AM
  1. Hotel guy

    HotelChatter Member

    Quality matters

    In my opinion quality matters when it comes to hotel WiFi. I have traveled extensively for many years and have seen excellent and worthless WiFi. One thing that is important to me is some sense of security.

    I was in a hotel in Hua Hin Thailand a few weeks ago that ran everything through an offsite squid proxy. The proxy blocked, and surely monitored all online activity making work almost impossible. Use a VPN if you have one, and check for proxies before entering sensitive information and passwords.

    Bangkok Cheap | Pattaya Cheap | Phuket Cheap

    August 15, 2009 at 12:18 PM
  1. Speakeasy602

    HotelChatter Member

    Not a hotel but...

    Don't use Starbucks WIFI, it sucks and it's expensive. LAME! Denny's actually has a free WIFI setup and as long as you're drinking coffee, they will loet you use it.

    Static Control
    ESD
    Anti Static Mats
    August 17, 2009 at 5:49 PM
  1. Aviie

    HotelChatter Member

    About the cost...

    I found the most expensive hotels does not offer WiFi for free! They charge for it.

    If all the hotels make it free for the guests, that would be really nice!

    August 18, 2009 at 3:56 PM
  1. napapo

    HotelChatter Member

    All Hotels should have free WiFi

    I think sooner or later all hotels will be forced to offer free WiFi to compete. As the number of travelers with laptops increases, more and more guests will base their decision on the availability and price of in-room internet service. Surprisingly, there are still a number of otherwise high quality hotels that seem to drop the ball when it comes to WiFi. Hopefully competition will prevail, and prices will slowly come down.

    The other factor is support. If a hotel is going to charge a hefty fee, then they should also have some quality support to go along with it. Hotels are often understaffed in this regard and the price should reflect this fact. If it's a five star resort, and a helpful tech comes to your room to resolve any issues you may be having, then charging a reasonable fee is acceptable.

    Bangkok Cheap hotel | Hotels Bangkok

    September 8, 2009 at 3:37 AM
  1. austrian

    HotelChatter Member

    Hotels wi-fi

    Surely all hotels should have free wi-fi, not only in the lobby but in the rooms as well. It is pretty natural considering that it is the end of 2009. Austria hotel In most European countries even the majority of 3star hotels have, although the connection speed might not be so great...
    September 18, 2009 at 3:00 AM
  1. Defaens

    HotelChatter Member

    Free Wifi Manila

    You can find here the list of free Wifi in Metro Manila
    October 11, 2009 at 8:14 AM
  1. jim2350

    HotelChatter Member

    Would be a great perk

    I though that wifi was pretty much standard in all hotels now
    October 17, 2009 at 10:34 AM
  1. John Montag

    HotelChatter Member

    (Comment Deleted)

    This comment has been deleted by markj.

    October 17, 2009 at 3:21 PM
  1. JamesAllisson

    HotelChatter Member

    The costs

    I understand, that many hotels don't want to pay to much for WiFi. Its a factor which is not unimportant, espacially for smaller hotels. But for business guests its important to work or have contact to other ones. For me as magician its important, too. Fortunately in germany the most hotels have WiFi.
    Zauberer and Tischzauberer
    October 22, 2009 at 3:04 AM
  1. Rent N Go

    HotelChatter Member

    info

    My biggest problem with this is you are on a beach, a beautiful beach, with fantastic tempratures and all you have to make you happy is WIFI? inchirieri auto | inchirieri masini
    October 22, 2009 at 4:23 AM
  1. Option Trader 18

    HotelChatter Member

    Must Have WiFi

    I won't stay anywhere that doesn't have reliable, high speed WiFi. Obviously, I prefer if it's free, but I don't mind paying for it as long as the service is good. I trade options for a living, so a reliable high speed connection isn't just something nice to have, it's a necessity for me. I really appreciate seeing this report. It'll definitely help me with travel plans in the future.
    November 1, 2009 at 9:13 AM
  1. adityabhat45

    HotelChatter Member

    hii

    you can also visit work from home.
    November 10, 2009 at 6:18 AM
  1. marinbrad

    HotelChatter Member

    Interesting

    That is very interesting and funny.  You definitely made my day with this awesome post. I am always searching for informative stuff like this! I will check here often for more cool stuff. continue with your speaking fearlessly!
    bbq aprons
    funny aprons
    November 21, 2009 at 10:20 AM

Leave a Comment

Not yet a member? Click here to become a member.

Already a member? Log in below:

Comment with your Facebook account.